Julian Sayin, Ohio State's starting quarterback, left the Buckeyes' 19-15 win at Indiana with an injury to his right arm and will miss time, with freshman Luke Fahey next in line.
How did Julian Sayin get hurt against Indiana?
Sayin was sacked on a first-and-10 play from Indiana's 38-yard line in the fourth quarter, according to Fox Sports. He fumbled on the play and the Buckeyes recovered, but Fox Sports reported that the injury appears to have happened there.
CBS Sports described the hit as coming from Indiana's Mario Landino and said Sayin was seen heading to the Ohio State locker room with his right arm hanging at his side. He came back out a few minutes later with the arm in a sling, CBS Sports reported.
Fox Sports put the exit at roughly eight minutes remaining in the fourth quarter. Sayin did not return to the game but was on the sideline for the finish, wearing the sling, according to Fox Sports.
- Sacked on first-and-10 from the Indiana 38
- Fumbled on the play; Ohio State recovered
- Left with about eight minutes left in the fourth quarter
- Returned to the sideline with right arm in a sling
What did Ryan Day say about the timeline?
The message changed over three days. Right after the game, Day told reporters Sayin would be out for several weeks, without giving specifics on the injury, according to CBS Sports. Fox Sports' Jenny Taft asked Day for an update on the field and he said he had none at that moment.
By Tuesday, three days after the game, Day told the media that no timeline would be set and that Sayin was out indefinitely, according to Fox Sports. Day added that, given the nature of the injury, the program was planning for him to be unavailable for the regular season and the postseason.
That is a wider window than the several-week estimate reported immediately after the game. No outlet has published a diagnosis.
What Ohio State has said about Sayin's absence
| When | What was said | Outlet |
|---|---|---|
| After the game | Out for several weeks, no injury specifics | CBS Sports |
| On the field, postgame | No update at that moment | Fox Sports |
| Tuesday, three days later | Out indefinitely; planning for no regular season or postseason | Fox Sports |

Who takes over at quarterback for the Buckeyes?
Luke Fahey, a true freshman, is in line to fill in, according to CBS Sports. He has been the first quarterback off the bench when Sayin has left games this season, and he replaced Sayin against Indiana with the top-five matchup still undecided.
Fahey's numbers are small but efficient. Entering the Indiana game he had appeared in three games, completing nine of 11 passes for 203 yards and two touchdowns, with both incompletions intercepted, according to CBS Sports. Against Indiana he went 0-for-2, and CBS Sports reported that Ohio State did not manage a first down with him in the game.
Ohio State also has sophomore quarterbacks Tavien St. Clair and Kolton Stover on the roster, according to CBS Sports. St. Clair, a five-star prospect and the No. 4 overall player in the 2025 signing class per 247Sports, has been the third-stringer and has attempted nine college passes, completing 5 of 6 for 52 yards and a touchdown against Ball State in Week 1.
Ohio State's quarterback room
| Player | Class | Status | Notable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Julian Sayin | Starter | Out indefinitely | 15-of-29, 235 yards, 2 TD, 2 INT vs. Indiana |
| Luke Fahey | True freshman | Next in line | 9-of-11, 203 yards, 2 TD, 2 INT before Indiana |
| Tavien St. Clair | Sophomore | Third string | 5-of-6, 52 yards, 1 TD vs. Ball State |
| Kolton Stover | Sophomore | Roster | No statistics reported |
What does the injury mean for Ohio State's playoff chances?
The win at Indiana lifted Ohio State to 6-1, with its only loss coming against Texas, according to Fox Sports. CBS Sports reported that the result gives the Buckeyes a top-five win on their resume and some cushion in the chase for a College Football Playoff berth.
The schedule does not offer much room to absorb a long absence. Ohio State is on a bye in Week 8, then travels to No. 19 USC on Oct. 31, according to CBS Sports. Oregon and No. 25 Northwestern follow at home, and games remain against Nebraska and Michigan, CBS Sports reported.
CBS Sports reported that if Sayin misses multiple games, the Buckeyes would be vulnerable against those opponents. Fox Sports noted that facing USC and Oregon with a true freshman at quarterback is a difficult prospect.
- Record: 6-1, lone loss to Texas
- Next game: at No. 19 USC on Oct. 31
- Then: Oregon and No. 25 Northwestern at home
- Also remaining: Nebraska and Michigan

How does this affect Jeremiah Smith's Heisman case?
Smith remains a frontrunner. CBS Sports reported that he was among the leading Heisman candidates after a dominant first six weeks, and Yahoo Sports called him the odds-on favorite. Fox Sports noted that Smith entered the weekend ranked second nationally and first in the Power Four with 916 receiving yards and 11 touchdowns.
Against Indiana he was largely contained: four catches for 68 yards, according to Yahoo Sports and CBS Sports. His 38-yard touchdown on fourth down, caught while covered, gave Ohio State a 19-7 lead and proved decisive, Yahoo Sports reported. CBS Sports put his season total after the game at 52 catches for 984 yards and 12 touchdowns.
The concern is volume. CBS Sports reported that Smith will now need to keep up that pace with a backup throwing him the ball. Fox Sports noted that Day had said before kickoff that the staff needed to get Smith as many touches as possible.
Jeremiah Smith at a glance
| Figure | Number | Outlet |
|---|---|---|
| Receiving yards before Week 7 | 916 | Fox Sports |
| Receiving touchdowns before Week 7 | 11 | Fox Sports |
| Catches vs. Indiana | 4 | Yahoo Sports |
| Yards vs. Indiana | 68 | Yahoo Sports |
| Season totals after Indiana | 52 catches, 984 yards, 12 TD | CBS Sports |
How did Ohio State win a game it nearly lost?
Indiana's 22-game winning streak ended on a matter of inches. Trailing 19-15 with just over a minute left, Indiana quarterback Josh Hoover found a wide-open Nick Marsh in the end zone, but Marsh's left foot came down out of bounds, according to CBS Sports and Fox Sports.
Indiana had stayed in the game in part because Sayin struggled before the injury. Fox Sports reported that the Hoosiers sacked him four times and intercepted him twice, the first multi-interception game of his career since Ohio State lost to Miami in last season's College Football Playoff. Yahoo Sports reported that Sayin turned the ball over three times.
Ohio State's defense carried the rest. Fox Sports reported that Matt Patricia's unit forced turnovers on each of Indiana's first two possessions of the third quarter, including a Jaylen McClain sack and forced fumble on fourth down, and held the Hoosiers to 8-of-18 on third and fourth down. Indiana's home winning streak ended at 19 games, according to Fox Sports.
- Final score: Ohio State 19, Indiana 15
- Indiana streak snapped: 22 games
- Indiana home streak snapped: 19 games
- Indiana third and fourth down: 8-of-18

Who is Luke Fahey, the freshman in the spotlight?
Fahey is a three-star recruit from Mission Viejo, California, according to CBS Sports and Fox Sports. CBS Sports reported that 247Sports rated him the No. 38 quarterback and the No. 46 prospect in California in the 2026 signing class, and listed him at 5-foot-11 and 206 pounds.
247Sports recruiting analyst Greg Biggins praised Fahey's accuracy and timing in a scouting report cited by CBS Sports. Biggins wrote that Fahey is "one of the most talented quarterbacks out West" and described him as quick to work through progressions.
His role grew faster than his recruiting ranking suggested. CBS Sports reported that Fahey had been the first quarterback off the bench whenever Sayin left a game, ahead of more heralded teammates.
What is still unconfirmed about Sayin's injury?
The diagnosis is not public. Neither CBS Sports nor Fox Sports reported the specific nature of the injury, and Day declined to give details after the game, saying only that it was a significant loss for the team.
The length of the absence is disputed between reports. CBS Sports and Newsweek reported a several-week absence; Fox Sports reported Day's Tuesday update that Sayin is out indefinitely, with the program planning for him to miss the regular season and the postseason.
It is also unclear which games Sayin will miss, whether he could return before the end of the regular season, and how Ohio State will divide first-team repetitions between Fahey and St. Clair. CBS Sports reported that Day has two weeks to decide who starts at USC.
What happens next for the Buckeyes?
Ohio State has a bye in Week 8, which gives the staff extra practices to settle the quarterback plan before the trip to USC on Oct. 31, according to CBS Sports. CBS Sports reported that Day needs that time to determine who should start against the Trojans.
In the meantime, CBS Sports reported that Ohio State will lean on a dominant defense and an improved rushing attack compared with last season. Fox Sports described the defense as championship-caliber after the Indiana performance.
The stakes are plain. CBS Sports reported that if the Buckeyes are going to contend for a national championship, they will need Sayin back in the lineup.
Questions readers ask
Is Julian Sayin out for the season?
Ohio State has not said that. Fox Sports reported that Day said Sayin is out indefinitely and that the program is planning for him to miss the regular season and postseason, which is not the same as a confirmed season-ending injury.
Did Ohio State beat Indiana?
Yes. Ohio State won 19-15 in Bloomington, ending Indiana's 22-game winning streak and its 19-game home winning streak, according to CBS Sports and Fox Sports.
Who is Ohio State's backup quarterback?
Luke Fahey, a true freshman from Mission Viejo, California, has been the first quarterback off the bench this season, according to CBS Sports. Tavien St. Clair and Kolton Stover are also on the roster.
Most read on News Porch
Two former FBI officials charged with lying to Congress about Hunter Biden laptop · By Evan R. Whitmore
Rome prosecutors open probe into Israeli minister over flotilla activists · By Evan R. Whitmore
Saudi Coalition Intercepts Missile Fired Towards Medina: A Side-by-Side Analysis · By Evan R. Whitmore
McDonald’s brings back Halloween Boo Buckets featuring Disney villains · By News Porch Editorial Team
Comparing Accounts of the Binari Village Attack in Nigeria · By Evan R. Whitmore



